Showing posts with label galo chiriboga. Show all posts
Showing posts with label galo chiriboga. Show all posts

Thursday, October 9, 2008

Correa lays it out

"You callin' my pint a poof?"

Sometimes things are calm and quiet down here. Sometimes events hit you so fast it's not even worth trying to keep up. An example of the second was yesterday's Ecuador, when five separate events hit in the space of an afternoon. Here's a brief summary and a bit of opinion on each one.

Ivanhoe (IVAN) a N.Am oil and gas, signed a contract to develop a very large heavy crude field in the country. IVAN seems to have been chosen for the job due to their technical abilities in extracting from this kind of field, but also thanks to some recent effective lobbying from the Canadian government.

Brazil's Odebrecht was told that its alternative offer to fix up the mess they made of the hydro complex construction wasn't good enough and they were confirmed as officially kicked out. On its own this shows Studmuffin laying down the law to foreigners, but taken in conjunction with the IVAN oil news it's even more symbolic. What I think Correa is saying to the world (with the timing as much as the events themselves), is "We'll work with foreign investment, but not at any old price". He's been consistent with this message, and so yesterday fits that plan.

Galo Chiriboga, the Minister of Energy and Petroleum, resigned citing "strictly personal reasons". After hearing from certain people in certain places, I can confirm that Chiriboga resigned due to illness...namely he's sick to the stomach of being bossed and bullied by Correa. Chiriboga has already been replaced by Derlis Palacios.

Palacios worked with Correa in 2005 when Studmuffin was FinMin so they seem to have a decent working relationship, but the MEM top position will continue to be a figurehead...the real boss of MEM was, is and certainly will continue to be Correa, and anyone can remember back to the time Correa decreed the 99% windfall tax on oil companies and Chiriboga only found out about the move at the press conference will know what I'm talking about. As regards things inside the ministry, it's likely to delay the workings as the new boy works his new broom and then gets down to work. Plenty of papers to read on mining before he can open his mouth, that's for sure.....

Roberto Andrade, President of the BCE (Ecuador Central Bank) resigned "in deference to his President". This one is the most ominous, I think. It's either "lapdog in to control the BCE and do exactly what Correa says", or Andrade has just resigned in protest about that which Correa is ready to unleash on the world regarding the so-called "illegal debt". Whatever it is, it can't be good. Fear ye bond holders!

Ecuador's Chancellor announced that there was a concerted plan to undermine Correa's image abroad. This one is no big worldshaker on the surface, but it does show how Studmuffin has got his minions running around, getting busy and worried about keeping their jobs. This will go down very (repeat very) well amongst the rank and file in Ecuador, who applaud action from their politicos and are allergic to lazy fatcat donothings in the ministerial seats. They'll also like the man-of-action image that Correa is projecting on a general level.

All in all, yesterday was all about Correa standing up and saying "Hey! Who da man?" WHO DA MAN?", and the world shouts back "You da man!". Let's see where this new, strong Correa takes us.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Ecuador and the mining windfall tax issue


Over at Ecuador Mining News Silvia Santacruz has written an interesting story on the ongoing "will-they-or-won't-they" story on the government and its plans (or non-plans) to charge a windfall tax (WFT) to the country's nascent mining industry.

Go see the whole story for yourself over at EMN, but in a nutshell gov't mining person Xavier Cordova made a speech at last week's Denver Mining bash and seemed to say that the gov't was going to scrap plans to charge the proposed WFT, citing the negative fallout that Mongolia had suffered in its mining sector since trying to introduce a WFT there. The speech was picked up in several places, but now EMN reports that it's received communication from José Serrano, (Cordova's boss) that says Ecuador still plans to charge the WFT. Silvia's piece does a good job in presenting the whole story, and adds links to relevant articles about the whole issue. Recommended reading.

So what's going on here? For a start, we're one week before a key election in Ecuador. This means that the gov't may be acting politically to shore up support amongst those who oppose mining in the country and might change their referendum vote to "no" on the 28th because of the whole issue. Or in other words, anything said by the Studmuffin gov't right now needs to be taken with a pinch of salt. Words words words.....this is LatAm! Gimme a signed piece of paper, then you have my real attention.

More importantly, as José Serrano seems to have pointed out in his mail to Silvia, the windfall tax is not a law that is controlled by the mining (and petroleum) ministry. It is strictly a fiscal law that comes from the taxation sector of Correa's government. Therefore Cordova can say what he likes about a WFT being bad or good in Mongolia. Serrano can, too. It's not up to them.

My feeling is that the truth lies somewhere in between the two positions. The WFT is not part of the new mining law (due out in October) but I'm pretty sure that the WFT will make it to the legislative books in Ecuador as part of the new fiscal package. However the practical application of the WFT is the most important part of all this. The WFT is slated as to be applied on a case-by-case basis, which means miner X may well end up paying more than miner Y, and for myriad reasons.

Also, the WFT is applied to a base case price for the metal, and that is open to adjustment from the mining ministry (presumably in conjunction with Studmuffin Correa himself). This means that if Ecuador so decides, it can say "Ok minerguys, if gold goes above $950/oz, or if copper goes above $3.50/lb you pay the WFT", but it could also say "Ok minerguys, no need to worry about the WFT until copper breaks $4.50/lb and gold's at $1,100/oz."

To sum all that up
1) Let's wait til after the 28th to find out the real story.
2) Let's see what the new mining law brings.
3) Even then, the mining law doesn't control the WFT.
4) And even when the gov't says "yes, we'll apply the 70% WFT as planned", the whole thing is still open to wide-ranging interpretation.

The bottom line is that anyone who expects the next few weeks will bring total closure on the market doubts about the future Ecuador's mining industry is going to be disappointed. I am confident that the whole package will be resolved in way that's fair to both sides at some point in the future. Just don't ask me 'when', ok?