Showing posts with label luis carranza. Show all posts
Showing posts with label luis carranza. Show all posts

Friday, August 21, 2009

Peru's economic liars: A primer for those who need to get up to speed

It has been brought to my attention that certain higher-traffic bloggers and financial commentators who were plug-dumb enough to buy into the "economic miracle" bunkum and lies spread by Peru's government and central bank lackeys (ably helped along by the dumbasses in suits at the IMF and World Bank) and were silly enough to regurgitate official numbers to their innocent flocks of readers have recently discovered IKN and are beginning to wake up, smell coffee and recognize they've been hoodwinked*.

And thus for their benefit, your humble correspondent has thrown together this little primer on the lies spread by this most pathetic of governments. First let's take in the figures in question via this chart:

And now let's hear what we've been told all this time:

January 19th: "Minister Carranza acknowledged the strength that characterizes the Peruvian economy....with a projected growth rate in 2009 of at least 6%. "

March 8th: "The results obtained from the leading indicator studies estimate an increase (of GDP) of 4.5%, 3.0% and 3.9% for the months of January, February and March 2009, respectively." (Peru official INEI stats office)

April 16th: Commenting on the February 0.17% growth rate registered, Carranza said, "February has been atypical and has been a pothole...additionally the impulse from the finance sector will show in the second quarter of the year."

May 5 2009: ""We likely hit the bottom in the first quarter, and we should see a stronger recovery in the second quarter," he (Carranza) told Reuters."

It goes on and on, with each and all this time your humble correspondent laughing tragic laughs and explaining how much bullshit is being spread by these unclothed emperors. Then finally, after half a year had gone by, some of the dumbasses in suits who fell for this crap for month after month up in gringoworld started seeing reason.

August 3rd: ""The lack of recovery signs following the first half 2009 growth collapse has many increasingly skeptical of Peru's growth story," said Merrill Lynch in a report Monday. "

But it's not just Spongebob Carranza, either. Goes without saying that Twobreakfasts is BSsing (his only talent), but as another example Peru's foreign trade minister Martin Perez is quoted in Newsweek as late as July 30th as saying:
" As a result of these actions, during the first half of the year, Peru's economy grew 0.9 percent. Martin Perez, Peru's minister of foreign trade and tourism, told Bloomberg he expects GDP to grow between 2.5 percent and 3 percent this year.

"Exports have suffered around 15 percent but the stimulus package the government has passed is trying to bring forth internal demand," he was quoted as saying by the magazine.
"
Now we can argue the toss about Peru's final 2009 figure if you like (for the record, he's still aiming high), but there are not one but two factually proveable incorrect statements in that short passage. Firstly, Peru's economy grew 0.34% in the first half of 2009 according to govt figures (that are also BS and way high) and not Perez's 0.9%. Secondly Perez says "exports have suffered around 15%" which is a barefaced lie. Peru's exports dropped 29.66% in the period in question, nigh on double Perez's balderdash. Again, official numbers. And as I hear you asking "what difference does it make anyway, Otto", let me tell you; that 15% understatement makes for two point four billion dollars in exports, or around 2% of Peru's GDP.

These people are liars. Plain and simple, look at the evidence above. This is the country that has a foreign trade minister overestimating foreign trade by $2.4Bn in Newsweek and because it's Amerika's friend nobody bothers to fact check, nobody questions, the nodding donkeys nod their heads and the moving finger, having writ, moves on. Meanwhile, here follows one segment from a whole plethora of posts at IKN that nailed the real story months and months ago. March 16th:
But don't let that worry you, because Twobreakfasts says it's going to be 5% this year, and Carranza says 5% this year, and the Central Bank says 5% this year, and the IMF says 5% this year. I mean, why on earth should you listen to me and ignore all those utterly reliable and impartial sources?
Therefore, the latest story from Spongebob is that Peru's GDP will grow by 2.5% in 2009 and will see "important improvement" to 5% in 2010. Are you going to take him at his word this time? Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice..............

Moral of this story: Be they your local mayor's office, your own country, Peru or LatAm or Asia or anywhere else you like, politicians do not tell the truth. However the mass hypnosis created by battering out the same "Peru miracle" story from all sources and feeding it to a compliant and brainless media means that the same lies and bullshit pervades into the financial commentaries of those with serious influence that are either 1) too stupid to work it out for themselves or 2) too lazy to bother checking the figures themselves before spreading the BS on. Yeah, that means you, "T"**.


*That was a mouthful of a paragraph, wasn't it?
**Before you mail and accuse me of bolshiness again note that I'm not naming you; my pathetic way of being nice, as I think you're saveable re LatAm.

Monday, August 17, 2009

Peru June GDP negative 2.08%

Read all about it here

Ah, that economic miracle. I wonder who's feeling the most stupid right now?
  • Spongebob and his "ya tocamos fondo" repeated this time every month?
  • Twobreakfasts and his "we're armour plated against the crisis" and his +6.5% GDP forecast for 2009?
  • S&P for giving the country invetsment grade and justifying its decision with talk of the "vibrant internal economy"...oh is that manufacturing down 15% again?
  • The idiots that actually thought GarcĂ­a would do a good job this time?

No, most likely the biggest idiots are the ones that still believe anything this government say, buy into the "we're still growing" tosh and nonsense and even go for the "we'll be fine in 2010" malarkey.

Friday, August 14, 2009

More downward revisions for Peru

And this time it's Spongebob and his band of liars at the Finance Ministry itself, downgrading to "between 2% and 3%" as reported by El Comercio last night. The downgrade will become official at the end of the month (when it'll probably be called plain straight 2%).

So let's look at how the official finance whores have forecast Peru 2009 so far in chart form. Now, I dunno 'bout you dude, but I kinda notice a trend developing...........

We do ornery (click to enlarge)

Otto, purveyor of an honest GDP forecast for all this time (1.28%) , guarantees further BS and downgrading as 2009 winds down. You seriously expect these people to be honest with you after that kind of track record?

Meanewhile, the pre-empted excuses for this month's disaster number (about to be published...should be a lotta fun) are already rolling out. This latest one made me laugh, the headline saying "According to analysts, economy fell 2% in June due to social protests". Y'see it isn't the Twobreakfast/Spongebob show that's at fault, oh no no no no no; it's those lousy commies that protest over nothing. But they can dress it up any way they like; Peru is falling further into recession on their watch, period. Truth beats out lies eventually.

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

Peru: Will Spongebob Carranza resign in disgrace as Peru slips further into recession?

When the last set of Peru GDP figures hit in July, FinMin and Liar Spongebob quickly came out and said that the economy "had touched bottom" (samo samo he's used all year) and said that the first half of 2009 would finish around +1%.
So inquiring minds would like to know whether Carranza will finally admit his policies have been utterly ineffective and that his constant overestimating bullshit has led his country up the garden path if the latest Banco Continental forecast of a Peru GDP downturn of -2% to -2.4% in June (the official number is expected out mid August) is proven true. According to the report:
"The Economics Studies Service of BBVA Banco Continental projects a fall in June GDP of between 2% and 2.4% after the poor performance (figures) of the primary and manufacturing sectors."
Such a figure would put Peru's GDP at around -1% negative growth for the first half of the year, a mile away from Spongebob's +1% for the first half of the year, a million miles from his 3% yearly forecast (that was as high as 5% in March) and a quadsquillion miles away from the total demagogic piffle spouted by Twobreakfasts late last year when he forecast Peru's 2009 as +6.5% and that his country's economy was "armour plated" against the world financial woes.
While we're at it, that 5% GDP figure mentioned by Carranza in March found its way into this IKN post at the time. A humble blogger like me calling bear on Peru all year against the world's economic brains calling "Peru economic miracle", so let's see now........
"... Twobreakfasts says it's going to be 5% this year, and Carranza says 5% this year, and the Central Bank says 5% this year, and the IMF says 5% this year. I mean, why on earth should you listen to me and ignore all those utterly reliable and impartial sources?"
Nuff said. I am available for hire or autographs so Spongebob, feel free to mail me you dumbass. You were a random walk FinMin who got lucky and did nothing during your first stint at the job, then actually bought into the BS they wrote about you. Fact is you're a zero, a liar, an emperor with no clothes and a knownothing. Resign and put us out of our misery.

Friday, July 17, 2009

Luis Carranza vs Sponge Bob

"Ya tocamos fondo" said FinMin and liar Luis Carranza about the Peruvian economy yesterday. Translated it mean "we've touched bottom" or "we've bottomed out" if you like. We also get to see the fruits of his Casio as he explains (and I shit thee not, kind reader):
"If, in the first six months, we end up by growing 1%, we'll need to grow in the second six months by around 5% to reach the 3% forecast at the end of the year."
I just hope and pray that he's dumbing himself down and trying to explain things to his audience of economy knownothings (i.e. Peruvian financial journalists), because if that's the limit of his analytical powers we're currently watching one of the greatest confidence tricks of the 21st century. And as for all that bottom touching stuff (saucy!), strangely that's the exact same thing this joke said in April...and May...and June for that matter.

But all this broken record stuff isn't the point of this post, because we have far more important things to discuss. Reader 'GP' writes in and says, "Have you noticed the similarity between Luis Carranza and Sponge Bob?". Well I hadn't in fact, so let's check the evidence:



Yep, you win a prize, GP. Nice call.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Luis Carranza rings the NYSE bell tomorrow morning.......

....and to celebrate the appearance of Peru's FinMin and liar, here are a few words written nearly 400 years ago that he might meditate on. After all, they are from Donne's Meditation number seventeen.

No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main; if a clod be washed away by the sea, Europe is the less, as well as if a promontory were, as well as if a manor of thy friend's or of thine own were; any man's death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind, and therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.


Thursday, July 2, 2009

Peru's GDP: Twobreakfasts is still in cloud cuckoo land

Click to enlarge

On March 17th, your humble correspondent called Peru's GDP for 2009 at 2.25% (as part of a friendly wager, see here). Right up to today the delusions of 3.5% growth this year persist at the Economy Ministry (FinMin Liar Carranza) and the Central Bank (slightly better Velarde, but still in a dream world).

However an important article in today's La Republica (screenshot above, link right here) makes is plain as day why these official forecasts are simply wrong. The economy is getting trashed, growth would have to average 4.8% for every month until December to make the gov't prediction, cement dispaches fell again last month, public works investment has ground to a virtual halt, prices are being cut left, right and centre as those affected push on their own strings, but this most awful of governments insists on its siren song of "everything's good...don't worry...think positively...we're doing just fine...investment grade, y'know...."

I was asked last week by a man who watches all things Peru economy closely just why I'm so harsh on the Peruvian situation. It's not because they're going through some kind of Russian recession (-11% right now, they tell me), it's because the country is so totally unprepared for what's about to happen. Before 2009, Chile was telling its people "look..we're about to hit a rough patch...get ready, people" but at the same time Twobreakfasts was ranting about how the Peruvian economy was armour plated against the world financial crisis, even though the economies of Peru and Chile are very similar. Amazingly, this ostrich-like attitude hasn't changed a jot in the ensuing 6 months. Peru is still unprepared for the shit that only now has begun to hit the fan. My problem with Peru isn't the comparative macro numbers, my problem is the vast, arrogant stupidity of its leaders that can't break the habit of lying to their people. How many more times must I read "ya hemos tocado fondo?". Dumbasses all.

Monday, June 15, 2009

Peru GDP drops 2.01%...Holy Trickledown, Batman!

Hard landing, anyone? Peru closing that gap....
  • FinMin and Liar Carranza expected "flat growth"
  • Lima suits expected -0.5%
  • Otto expected something around -0.7% by comparing Peru with Chile

But the result is much, much worse. Peru's April GDP figure has just been announced, and it's -2.01% YoY. That's bad enough, but the shocker is manufacturing growth at -13.64%. Fishery at -24.19% is bad, too. Then there are others, like the supposed motor of construction that dropped 1.48% and commerce down 2.29%. And it could have been worse if Peru were honest about mining, too. Despite 10,000 layoffs this year and far lower prices for products, Peru insists its mining industry has grown 2.77% YoY.

So much for February being a simple "pothole in the road" as Liar Carranza insisted at the time. So much for Twobreakfasts and his "armour plated economy". Right now the gov't is trying to make a lot of the fact that April 2009 had two less working days than April 2008....funnily enough the same moaners and wailing weren't worried about the two days added on to March'09 figures, though.

The only difference between the economies Peru and Chile is that the Chilean gov't is honest with its people and has made more provisions for the tough times ahead. Apart from that, they're both well in recession.

Friday, June 5, 2009

In Peru, simply announcing a plan adds to GDP....

.....and nobody cares whether it ever becomes reality.

The big Twobreakfasts plan to save Peru from recession is the "PEE" (Plan de EstĂ­mulo EconĂłmico or Economic Stimulus Plan). The whole idea is basically pumping a shitload of money into the economy via public works (roads, build schools, hospitals...a whole list of stuff like that) using funds tucked away for the rainy day. The liars at FinMin came up with a plan to spend U$2.5Bn in 2009 which would, according to their skewed slide rules, add 3% GDP growth to Peru this year and save the country from the abyss.

Well here we are six months down the line and how is the plan coming along?

Oh dear.

Of the $2.5Bn aimed at Peru from the government coffers, only U$390m has been or is being spent right now. According to this report in South America's 'serious' bizpress, AmericaEconomia, 16% of planned national works are or have happened, regional governments have executed 12% of their plans and local governments have m,anaged to get 15% of their plans going. Anyone who knows anything at all about LatAm bureaucracy will not be at all surprised, as most of the time they're trying to work out how much of the slush can end up in their own back pockets. In fact, it's interesting to speculate on just how much of that supposed $390m number has been diverted, never to be seen again (and certainly never to be turned into cement, rebar or tarmacadam).

There's more chance of Diego Maradona bedding Keira Knightley than there is of this plan adding 3% to Peru's GDP this year, but I doubt anyone in the higher echelons of Twobreakfastslandia cares a damn because there's always INEI available to fix the figures for them. Style above substance? Of course! It's South America, dude.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

Ridicule for Peru's economic numbers is getting louder


Up to recent times, criticism for the methods and results that attempt to substantiate Peru's economic miracle has been confined to a small group of hardcore economists, but now that's changing. The mainstream of Peruvian economists and even the most officialist and supine of its media outlets are voicing open and loud criticism at the way the figures are calculated and the obvious (really, truly obvious) inflation of results.

All the normal anti-Alan outlets have been pounding on this for a while, of course, but this report in El Comercio marks a turning of the tide. For those unaware, El Comercio is by nature supportive of the government (including Presidents from Fujimori, through Paniagua, Toledo and Twobreakfasts) but has a particular soft spot for the APRA party as they tend to favour the newspaper's owners with juicy construction contacts and other "legal" favours.

So when El Comercio reports on the stench rising from Peru's statistics office and the numbers massaged to an inch of their life, watch out. In the report El Comercio has a whole group of local names lined up and voicing their doubts, including site friend Jurgen Schuldt (who is, after all, a highly respected economist at the Universidad del Pacifico in Lima), Bruno Seminario (ditto very respected, ditto Pacifico) Kurt Burneo (ex head of the Banco Nacion, no less), Eduardo Morón, José Marthans and other names you'll not have heard of unless you care about the intellectual society in Lima.

On his blog this week, Schuldt really sums up the whole problem in one neat paragraph. Not a man to go for the hyperbole, he notes that the March GDP headline number is +3.05% and is left scratching his head when looking at the numbers that compose that growth:

"..It becomes difficult to understand how the "other services" sector could have grown 7% (that explains 86% of the total growth!) at the same time that there were abrupt falls in industrial manufacturing (-5.4%) and tax revenues for April (-18%) as mentioned by Farid Matuk and Bruno seminario amongst others questioning the amateur surgery being practiced in the INEI."

Exactly. That the sector "other services" is calculated in a totally secretive and non-transparent black box manner also screams manipulation, too. Put in very basic terms, all of the INEI figures that are collected in a public and verifiable way point to the same thing: Peru is in recession. But somehow, mysteriously, the Wizzrd of Ozness that goes on at the INEI means that these clear negative numbers are counterweighted by figures for other, non survey measurements that say "no, everything's ok..seriously...look at this number."

It's bull. Chile is in recession to the tune of 2.1%, as announced today. Chile is a strong country financially that relies very heavily on exports of metals to grow. Peru's export mix is uncannily similar to that of Chile but wants us to believe that it's growing 5% more than its Southern neighbour even though its financial system is weaker and political stability far more precarious. And it bases its argument on a set of cooked up black box numbers. It's ridiculous indeed, it's asinine, it's an insult to the intelligence. Three adjectives that can also be used to describe Peru's President, as after all that "get what they deserve" phrase works just as well down here.

Friday, May 15, 2009

Luis Carranza, Finance Minister of Peru and barefaced liar


It always happens eventually; the liar gets caught in his lie.

Yesterday Peru's FinMin and nation's number two liar Luis Carranza (numero uno above) gave a presentation on the prospects for his country's economy. If anyone wants a copy of the powerpoint show (49 slides of fun with dense numbers, graphs with arrows pointing UP! UP! UP! and Spanish language) send me a mail, but suffice to say the whole idea must have been to blow smoke in the eyes of the dumbass nodding donkey journalists present. That's because anyone with a basic understanding of economics....and i mean basic really is enough...can see just how much BS was on display yesterday.

For one thing, the full-on statistician Farid Matuk was quick to point out that MEF has quietly dropped something called GDP elasticity from 3 to 1. What this means in practical terms is that they are suddenly toeing the line of the Central Bank and assuming a currency devaluation to maintain growth at all costs (esp to the cost of those poor Limeños with mortgages in dollars). However a different statistic that I noted was that the breakdown of Carranza's fantasy 3.5% GDP growth this year assumes a 5% growth in mining GDP.

Whaaaaaaaaaaaaat?????? We're supposed to believe that Peru's mining industry will contribute 5% more this year than it did last year...remember copper at $4/lb, Zinc and Lead at $1/lb and silver at $18/oz, people? Here's a chart using final metals exports as a proxy to total GDP activity in Peru's mining sector (as nearly all the metal produced in Peru is exported). We see the 2008 export figures for Peru, the first three months of 2009 and what Peru will need to export to get that 5% growth Carranza masturbates about.


It's asinine. It's just a heap of barefaced lies. Nothing else. There's no way that monthly exports can suddenly jump from under $1.1bn to over $1.83Bn and stay at that average for the rest of the year. More likely is a $6bn gap between the cash Carranza wants and the cash he's going to get. And $6Bn in Peru is a significant chunk of annual GDP.

There's only one question left to answer now: Will this man do the honourable thing and resign when his ridiculous economic projections are proven false by the end of this year?

Friday, May 8, 2009

Peru macro news

This time of the month there's always a swathe of macro econ news from LatAm countries. When it comes to Peru, there are plenty of ingredients to throw in the cake mix.

1. Trade Balance: The March trade balance came in positive, with $1.56Bn in imports and $1.9Bn in exports. The export figure has benefitted directly from the rebound in metals prices. Here's the chart.
Looks like things have picked up a touch month-over-month, which is good. However there's still that very large year-over-year gap in activity, which isn't so good.

2. Tax Revenues: Unsurprisingly, taxes levied on external trade traffic are down. However as this WSJ report notes, income tax revenues are also sharply down (21%) for April YoY. This points to a significant slowdown in internal demand. Overall, tax collection was down 17.8% YoY....not funny.

3. The Nuevo Sol (PEN) is now trading at S/2.96 to the dollar, having moved from the 3.10 mark very quickly. This stronger PEN is now affecting export trade competitivity and the Central Bank is moving to stop the melt-up. It bought into the market to the tune of U$7m yesterday , which isn't so very much but should send a signal. With currency reserves back at U$31Bn, Velarde has plenty of ammunition to stop the PEN from strengthening too far.

4. Interest rates: The reason for the stronger currency is likely the interest rates on offer in (what they insist is) an investment grade country attracting overseas money (it can hardly be called 'hot money' these days...maybe lukewarm?). It is a bit pachakuti to think that Peru is considered a safe haven these days, isn't it? So yesterday we saw the CenBank drop rates to 4% and you can bet decent cash that the trend will continue in the months to come.

As for the conclusion to all this, I'll be writing up my views in The IKN Weekly. It's called "another pitch", but it's also about preferring the paying subcribers. Life's like that.

Friday, April 17, 2009

Luis Carranza, Man in Denial


Yesterday Peru's increasingly embarrassing FinMin, Luis Carranza, said that first quarter GDP growth would come in at 3% and his full year forecast was still 4%. He alled the February 0.19% disaster a "pothole"....potsmoke is more apt under the circumstances, as Luis is obviously been toking the waccybaccy.

So let's check on this blathering. First Carranza's quarterly forecast January was 3.1%, February was 0.19%, so to get a 3% average for 1q09 we'll need March to come in at 5.7% or so. I mean, even his own ministry is calling March at 3%, and that's the highest forecast out there...and by a long way.

Secondly his 4% growth target for the year. I refer you, kind and gentle lector of IKN, back to the theoretical projections chart of yesterday, reprinted here.


The above isn't my estimate or guessworrk, this is just plain old mathematics and numbercrunching. Put simply even if Peru knocks out a 4% average monthly growth from here to December Peru's GDP comes up short of 4%.

He pins his hopes on a $3Bn stimulus package that doesn't even get close to covering the difference in copper revenues in 2009 (forget all other exports....just copper is going to drop by at least $4Bn). He cites the fact that fishery will pick up in March but forgets it's only 0.72% of GDP weighting, conveniently ignoring the disastrous 7.45% drop in manufacturing output that will surely repeat.

Look, this stuff isn't tough economics and Carranza knows his subject, so he's either suddenly developed a nasty case of stupid or he knows he's lying through his teeth.

Go on...take a wild guess....

Thursday, April 16, 2009

The IKN forecast for Peru's GDP in 2009

Enough of just laughing at the neverending downward revisions of the dumbasses in suits, it's time to nail colours to the mast. Yesterday's February GDP numbers from Peru were downright horrible. No ifs, no buts, no maybes. So instead of getting on with my life last night I started to play with some previously tweaked models and then whipped up a couple of charts from them, too.

This first chart shows how Peru's 2009 GDP number will evolve (devolve?) in 2009 under five different and purely theoretical growth scenarios. From a highly optimistic 4% growth per month to a 0% average growth scenario.

Note that with this chart above even a 4% monthly growth rate from here will end up with a lower 2009 GDP than is being forecast by Peru's Central Bank, its Finance Ministry, the IMF and all the other liars. And to repeat: February GDP came in at 0.19%. March GDP is likely YoY flat or negative. Same for April. Etc etc.

Now this second chart is my best case (honestly, this is being optimistic) for Peru in 2009. The yellow bars show the monthly GDP figures and the red bars are the 12 month trailing GDP forecasts. And so after the shocking numbers posted yesterday, right now I'm predicting Peru to grow 1.28% in 2009. As for 2010, almost certain recession.


Moral: Miracles are for the religions, not economics. Welcome to reality.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Peru GDP revision watch: Carranza gets in on the act

Luis Carranza is either an outright liar or he's feeling very, very stupid right now. Today El Comercio reports the latest downgrade in Peru's GDP expectations with Peru's FinMin having to eat a plateful of crow just weeks after insisting that Peru's GDP is set on course for 5% this year. Let's see how his 3% number fits in with all the other BS calls so far:


And it's still only April! Remember Otto's call of 2.25%, folks.

Monday, March 2, 2009

Look into my eyes, Peru.......


A truly frightening display of idiocy was on show for viewers of Peru's TV program "El Cuarto Poder" last night. Finance Minister Luis Carranza was interviewed on show and managed to pack in haughty arrogance, arch stupidity and a full-on attempt at mass-hypnosis in the space of just ten minutes. Here's an Ottotrans™ of some direct quotes:

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
"The most important is that they (the Peruvian people) are relaxed and continue making their consumption, savings and investment decision with a long-term view and not on account of bad news that might appear one day in a newspaper or from a pessimistic analyst.

He then went on to ask people not to be carried away by negativity because the government has the clear objectives to maintain growth and reduce poverty. And then...

"The important thing is to be relaxed and be safe in the knowledge that in the government we are doing everything we can and we have the strength to maintain GDP and employment growth according to our needs."
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Repeat after me:
"The Government Will Look After You."
"I'm From The Government And I'm Here To Help You."
"Every Day In Every Way I'm Getting Better And Better."
"Fitter, Stronger, More Productive."

So as you can imagine, Otto is sure his words went down well with the 10,000 Peruvian miners laid off in the first two months of 2009. Certain that the 45% drop in real estate sales registered in Lima in the final three months of 2008 will immediately bounce back thanks to Carranza's soothing words. And how can there be any doubt that the ZERO PERCENT CURRENT GROWTH registered by local experts (when they don't swallow the gov'ts massaged numbers whole) will immediately pick up again thanks to Luis's performance last night?

To round off his pep-talk last night, Carranza reminded the world yet again that the IMF had predicted 5% growth for Peru in 2009. Hey wow..the IMF...they're serious people and never get it wrong in South America. Or perhaps not.

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Musical chairs, twobreakfasts style

As his President enters the room, Luis Valdivieso
shields his eyes from the glare of his smile

Remember about a month ago when Peru's FinMin Luis Miguel Valdiveso suddenly and unexpectedly resigned? Remember how his predecessor Luis "luckiest economist in LatAm" Carranza stepped up to take his place? Remember how, in the hasty and brief press conference Valdivieso said he'd been offered an alternative job by President Twobreakfasts?

Well yesterday the episode cleared itself up and Valdivieso was named as Peru's new ambassador of the United States of America, no less. It's all pretty logical on the superficial level, of course. Luismi was an IMF flunkey for years and knows the protocol side of the US backwards. He's also replacing the current Peruvian ambassador, Felipe Ortiz de Zevallos, who strangely and coincidentally handed in his resignation on January 21st, the day after Valdivieso resigned.

But it does shed a little light on the way Twobreakfasts is thinking (if the term is apt) on the Peruvian economy. He clearly wanted Carranza back, as the guy has a higher profile than Valdivieso and is (due to his incredibly lucky timing) credited as being a good hands-on economy manager. In fact he just continued the autopilot that came from the real architect of the Peruvian economy reforms, PPK, and did nothing much....the 'ain't broke don't fix it' rule. But style is far more important than substance in The World According To Twobreakfasts and Carranza's arrival has been an APRA spindoctors dream.

But once again, IKN wonders why Carranza came back and how Twobreakfasts got him to agree. When Carranza first resigned his post, the reason was that he wasn't making enough money as FinMin and wanted to get a nice cushy, highly paid gig in some private consultancy. Yeah, truly, it was said out loud right here by then PM Del Castillo and reported by your diligent IKN. It's kind of intriguing to think about all the recent corruption scandals in this awful Peruvian APRA government and then think that Carranza suddenly finds the FinMin job attractive once again, is it not?

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Peru's GDP growth miracle revealed


I've been sitting here this morning wondering how Peru's FinMin liar Carranza can possibly claim his country will grow by 5% and "lead the world in growth" in 2009, while neighbour Chile (a far more serious nation) predicts its growth at a mere 1.2% (a wholly believable figure, FWIW). And I've come to the only possible conclusion that makes any logical sense:

It must be the bus accidents.

Peru is a notoriously dangerous place to travel by road, with a lax and corrupt government that takes bribes from lax and corrupt bus companies so that they never ask too many questions about the way they run their plant and drivers into the ground for the sake of an extra dollar in profit. I mean, if you have two drivers working 12 hour shifts it beats the hell out of 3 doing eight hours each, does it not? And who needs new rubber on tires anyway?

In fact the last 24 hours have been pretty typical on the highways and byways of Peru, with this crash yesterday killing 10 and another crash in this report killing 14 people this morning. But the thing is, if you base your life on GDP as the prime measurement for a country's development, these horrific deaths are good news for Peru. It works like this:

Upside: Here's an approximation of all the economic activity the two bus crashes are creating:

24 funerals @ U$1,000 = U$24,000
Media coverage
(reporter's pay, extra newspaper copies sold etc) = U$50,000
Cost of three replacement buses = U$240,000

Emergency services attention
(single crew for 24 hours per accident) =U$7,000

Then the downside, as you have to subtract what these people would have earned during the year if they weren't now dead.

Subtract 24 lost salaries at National Average for 2009 = -U$96,000

Final Benefit to Peru = $225,000

Or in other words, by killing these 24 people on the roads of Peru, the country has managed to triple their contribution to country GDP in 2009! With so many accidents and deaths reported on Peru's highways every year, it's not surprising after all that it will outgrow Chile in 2009.

And if you're looking at this post and thinking it's a trick, believe me that this is a pretty fair ballpark on how GDP calculations work. For example, the bushfires in Australia right now will be looked upon as a benefit by economists. I betcha Twobreakfasts is hoping for another big earthquake this year.

Monday, January 26, 2009

News from 'Investment Grade' Peru, part 829


Jacqueline Fowks at her impressive Spanish language blog 'noticias desde lenovo' brings us another tale of Peru. Remember this is the country feted by all and sundry, especially the all-seeing-all-knowing band of idiots known as economists that have been proven 100% wrong with all their models recently.

This is the country that has supposedly grown like a rocket. This is the country whose FinMin bullshit liar Luis Carranza said in November 2007 that the effects of trickledown economics were being felt by all Peruvians. All of them. Understand the word "all"? Now read on, and find out what things are like in Andahuaylas, Peru:

"...the mothers of children under two years old receive diverse aid, amongst them food complements that are not only destined for the undernourished child but also to the other children (in the family) as they do not have enough to eat, either.

The mothers comply with the program instructions up to a certain point in time, because if the children reach the age of two and have moved away from being malnutrition cases they are taken off the program. So two months before the age of two the mother begins to undernourish the child so that it stays on the list of those that receive food complements."

Remember that this is the very same region recently mentioned where women get pregnant in order to receive 100 soles per month from the government.

Viva investment grade. Viva viva viva.

Monday, January 19, 2009

Peru's Finance Minister admits he can't do the job and quits, giving the job back to another quitter

Goodbye overrated lardass, hello overrated lardass.
Valdivieso (left) quits and Carranza (right) is back


So farewell Luis Miguel Valdivieso, best remembered as the fat guy who took over from the other fat guy as Peru's FinMin and talked nonsense about Peru's economy for six months or so. I still have fond memories of his Bistromatics attack on August 21st last year when he claimed Peru's inflation rate (then at 5.7%) would finish the year at 5.8%. The final score was 7.24%, which isn't bad for an ex-IMF lackey who'd never faced reality before but an eight-year old with the inflation chart and a straight-edged ruler could have done better. Word is that Valdivieso is quitting due to illness; he's sick to death of taking orders from his rat-faced new boss Yehude Simon.

The great news is that the fat guy he replaced is coming back to replace him. Luis Carranza, the luckiest economist on the planet who inherited a booming economy, ran it on autopilot for two years and then picked the right time almost to the month to quit and run away is taking the FinMin job back again. Otto finds this very strange, as Carranza's ostensible reason for quitting at the time was that his own funds were low and they just didn't pay him enough at the Ministry. Therefore his reappearance seems to suggest one of three things:

1) He couldn't find a cushy job in the private sector and he couldn't get enough of those paid evening speaker jobs to make ends meet. This is likely because it isn't just Otto who recognizes his mediocrity.

2) Like the rest of us he's noticed the rampant corruption and slush money swirling in and around the Twobreakfasts administration and wants his piece of the action. Wadya expect from the APRA boyz anyway? Justice?

3) He was talking total bollocks. Also highly likely, as he made a specialty of it in his first term of office.

Combinations of the above are acceptable, of course. So now that Peru is in the doo-doo and still won't admit it, we're about to see just how good Carranza really is. Otto has a friend who has constantly stuck up for Carranza and his record over the years. To that person I say "Betcha ten bucks yer man makes a hash of it all and shows just how mediocre he's always been". One thing Carranza was famous for during his last tenure was totally ignoring and despising his counterpart at the Central Bank, Velarde. Let's see if they get all touchy-feely this time around because it's going to be tough to run an anti-crisis plan if Carranza starts his primadonna antics again.