Showing posts with label liar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label liar. Show all posts

Friday, August 21, 2009

Peru's economic liars: A primer for those who need to get up to speed

It has been brought to my attention that certain higher-traffic bloggers and financial commentators who were plug-dumb enough to buy into the "economic miracle" bunkum and lies spread by Peru's government and central bank lackeys (ably helped along by the dumbasses in suits at the IMF and World Bank) and were silly enough to regurgitate official numbers to their innocent flocks of readers have recently discovered IKN and are beginning to wake up, smell coffee and recognize they've been hoodwinked*.

And thus for their benefit, your humble correspondent has thrown together this little primer on the lies spread by this most pathetic of governments. First let's take in the figures in question via this chart:

And now let's hear what we've been told all this time:

January 19th: "Minister Carranza acknowledged the strength that characterizes the Peruvian economy....with a projected growth rate in 2009 of at least 6%. "

March 8th: "The results obtained from the leading indicator studies estimate an increase (of GDP) of 4.5%, 3.0% and 3.9% for the months of January, February and March 2009, respectively." (Peru official INEI stats office)

April 16th: Commenting on the February 0.17% growth rate registered, Carranza said, "February has been atypical and has been a pothole...additionally the impulse from the finance sector will show in the second quarter of the year."

May 5 2009: ""We likely hit the bottom in the first quarter, and we should see a stronger recovery in the second quarter," he (Carranza) told Reuters."

It goes on and on, with each and all this time your humble correspondent laughing tragic laughs and explaining how much bullshit is being spread by these unclothed emperors. Then finally, after half a year had gone by, some of the dumbasses in suits who fell for this crap for month after month up in gringoworld started seeing reason.

August 3rd: ""The lack of recovery signs following the first half 2009 growth collapse has many increasingly skeptical of Peru's growth story," said Merrill Lynch in a report Monday. "

But it's not just Spongebob Carranza, either. Goes without saying that Twobreakfasts is BSsing (his only talent), but as another example Peru's foreign trade minister Martin Perez is quoted in Newsweek as late as July 30th as saying:
" As a result of these actions, during the first half of the year, Peru's economy grew 0.9 percent. Martin Perez, Peru's minister of foreign trade and tourism, told Bloomberg he expects GDP to grow between 2.5 percent and 3 percent this year.

"Exports have suffered around 15 percent but the stimulus package the government has passed is trying to bring forth internal demand," he was quoted as saying by the magazine.
"
Now we can argue the toss about Peru's final 2009 figure if you like (for the record, he's still aiming high), but there are not one but two factually proveable incorrect statements in that short passage. Firstly, Peru's economy grew 0.34% in the first half of 2009 according to govt figures (that are also BS and way high) and not Perez's 0.9%. Secondly Perez says "exports have suffered around 15%" which is a barefaced lie. Peru's exports dropped 29.66% in the period in question, nigh on double Perez's balderdash. Again, official numbers. And as I hear you asking "what difference does it make anyway, Otto", let me tell you; that 15% understatement makes for two point four billion dollars in exports, or around 2% of Peru's GDP.

These people are liars. Plain and simple, look at the evidence above. This is the country that has a foreign trade minister overestimating foreign trade by $2.4Bn in Newsweek and because it's Amerika's friend nobody bothers to fact check, nobody questions, the nodding donkeys nod their heads and the moving finger, having writ, moves on. Meanwhile, here follows one segment from a whole plethora of posts at IKN that nailed the real story months and months ago. March 16th:
But don't let that worry you, because Twobreakfasts says it's going to be 5% this year, and Carranza says 5% this year, and the Central Bank says 5% this year, and the IMF says 5% this year. I mean, why on earth should you listen to me and ignore all those utterly reliable and impartial sources?
Therefore, the latest story from Spongebob is that Peru's GDP will grow by 2.5% in 2009 and will see "important improvement" to 5% in 2010. Are you going to take him at his word this time? Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice..............

Moral of this story: Be they your local mayor's office, your own country, Peru or LatAm or Asia or anywhere else you like, politicians do not tell the truth. However the mass hypnosis created by battering out the same "Peru miracle" story from all sources and feeding it to a compliant and brainless media means that the same lies and bullshit pervades into the financial commentaries of those with serious influence that are either 1) too stupid to work it out for themselves or 2) too lazy to bother checking the figures themselves before spreading the BS on. Yeah, that means you, "T"**.


*That was a mouthful of a paragraph, wasn't it?
**Before you mail and accuse me of bolshiness again note that I'm not naming you; my pathetic way of being nice, as I think you're saveable re LatAm.

Wednesday, April 8, 2009

Peru GDP revision watch: Carranza gets in on the act

Luis Carranza is either an outright liar or he's feeling very, very stupid right now. Today El Comercio reports the latest downgrade in Peru's GDP expectations with Peru's FinMin having to eat a plateful of crow just weeks after insisting that Peru's GDP is set on course for 5% this year. Let's see how his 3% number fits in with all the other BS calls so far:


And it's still only April! Remember Otto's call of 2.25%, folks.

Friday, February 20, 2009

Still don't believe that US reporters lie to you about LatAm?

Well read this.

Some idiot who thinks he's special because he got hired by The Washington Post named Joshua Partlow has been conclusively shown as a know-nothing liar and peddler of proven falsehoods that were ordered retracted by court order over a year ago. And surprise surprise, Partlow was spreading BS muck about...wait for it.......roll on the drums....yes....you've guessed it already...Venezuela, Bolivia and Ecuador! Wow, shocker, huh?

All this thanks to the diligent work of excellent (and I'm proud to say long-time linked here) blogs Abiding In Bolivia and The Mex Files (and their own mini-eminence gris Utpal.) Click on the blognames to find the full exposés to Partlow's lies. Good work, guys.

So Joshua, you receive an award that so many professional journalists who read IKN have deserved this week. All yours, dumbass:

Sunday, February 8, 2009

Alan Garcia is a liar: Some empiricals

At the same time President Twobreakfasts was waxing lyrical about Peru's stability and how it was shielded from the world recession and how Peru's GDP would grow 6.5% in 2009 (date, November 2008), the following was happening to Peru's trade balance:

And as bad as that chart looks, if you look further it actually gets worse. This second chart shows the import/export breakdown that results in the above trade balance. As you can see, the slowdown in both sides of the equation adds further recessionary pressure:

Developing nations such as Peru rely on export capacity to drive economic growth. No exports = no growth. That's a bit of cruel reality Economics 101 for you, dudes. S&P, Fitch and all the others can try to hoodwink you into believing that the internal economy is Peru's new driver but that is just so much crap, sad to say. Peru is not a strong currency nation that can run an indefinite trade deficit with the rest of the world; its ability to grow is totally dependent on its ability to sell to other places. And that chart up there is not good news.

It's not about unduly knocking a country or a region (as accused yesterday by some dumbass), it's about looking at the facts, telling the truth and not listening to obvious bullshit from obvious bullshitters. The main reason why Peru is in more trouble than (for example) Chile is that Chile is being mature about its future problems. The government of Peru is still jawboning its people into believing that everything is fine. That Peru GDP forecast is now down to 5%, by the way. It's going lower. Take that to the bank.